We advised you to vote for the depressed candidate or the laughing candidate, but on the campaign trail, humor may be in the eyes of the viewers. When presidential candidates poke fun at themselves or at opponents, viewers take away different impressions of the humor and of the candidates, based on previously held opinions.
During the 2008 election season, political scientist Patrick A. Stewart studied how viewers evaluated humorous comments by candidates. He used humorous comments delivered by presidential candidates Barack Obama and John McCain in a non-partisan venue, the annual Alfred E. Smith Memorial Foundation Dinner to benefit Catholic charities, held just 19 days before the election. He found that previously held opinions about the candidates influenced participants’ evaluations of the humorous comments. In turn, the evaluations of the humor influenced how participants saw both the source and the target of the humor.
He says, "Pre-existing candidate evaluation plays the strongest role in the equation." The more positively participants rated a candidate's likeability, intelligence, honesty, compassion and electability, the higher they rated the candidate’s humorous comment in terms of it making sense, being playfully told and being funny. In the end, a candidate's sense of humor made little change in how participants evaluated them. So candidates are advised to play it safe, and can the humor during speeches and debates.
Here's something funny: how many people tell us how much they love the great edge news on our website, but don't SUPPORT us! Despite having no advertising on other media, we have 60% more readers and listeners than we did a year ago, through word-of-mouth alone. Now if only more of you would subscribe today, there's a chance we might still be here tomorrow--and maybe in 2012 as well (NOTE: You can get $3 off our beautiful new crop circle calendar if you use coupon 2012 by Friday, September 23). And speaking of 2012, Whitley Strieber wrote a novel with that title, which is available in the NEW Whitley Strieber Collection, and comes with an autographed bookplate he designed himself!)